Blu-Ray vs. HD-DVD
By Cssio Lima on January 18, 2007


Introduction

Blu-Ray and HD-DVD are two new optical storage technologies that fight as the successor of DVD. In this article you will learn everything you need to know about these technologies, including the motivations that lead to the creation of both. Is it really true that DVD has its days counted?

With the introduction of high-definition TV (HDTV) DVD storage capacity showed to be insufficient to this application. DVD supports a resolution up to 720x480 pixels, while HDTV works with resolutions as high as 1920x1080 pixels. Just to give you an idea, two hours of high-definition video with data compression requires 22 GB of storage space. Keep in mind that the maximum capacity of a DVD is of 17 GB, if a DVD-18 disc is used (keep in mind that this is a dual-sided dual-layer disc).

So how to allow a higher data storage capacity in order to support high-definition contents? Here is where two DVD successor candidates enter in scene: Blu-Ray and HD-DVD.

In fact a Blu-Ray or a HD-DVD is a DVD disc with a higher storage capacity, allowing you to store high-definition contents. It is important to remark that the main motivation to the creation of a DVD successor was the introduction of HDTV, which requires a higher disc storage capacity, feature a regular DVD cannot provide.

But how a Blu-Ray or a HD-DVD disc is able to store more data than a DVD disc? That is exactly what we will discuss in the next page.

Blu-Ray vs. HD-DVD

Blu-Ray technology was developed in February 2002 to be DVDs successor by a consortium made by companies that include Apple, Dell, Hitachi, HP, JVC, LG, Mitsubishi, Panasonic, Pioneer, Phillips, Samsung, Sharp, Sony, TDK and Thomson. HD-DVD, on the other hand, was created by Toshiba and recently got support from Microsoft, HP and Intel.

Both Blu-Ray and HD-DVD discs have the same physical size of DVD discs (and CDs), with a diameter of 12 cm (120 mm, around 4 ).

The key to both Blu-Ray and HD-DVD technologies is the use of a blue-purple laser to read and write data from the disc. This laser has a smaller wavelength compared to the red laser used by DVD players, allowing a higher recording density.

During the recording of a Blu-Ray or HD-DVD disc a high-power blue-purple laser is used to burn pits on the disc surface. The areas than werent burned are known as lands.

During the reading of a Blue-Ray or HD-DVD disc a blue-purple laser with lower intensity is thrown on the disc surface. When the light reaches a pit it is reflected back with a lower intensity compared when it hit a land. As the pit height corresponds to of the laser wavelength, the reflected light reaches the photosensor found on the Blu-Ray or HD-DVD player half wavelength dephased ( on its way in + on its way back = ). This is how the Blu-Ray or HD-DVD player can recognize if an area is a pit or a land: the amount of light reflected by a land is higher than the amount reflected by a pit.

You could think that each spot where the light is reflected with a higher intensity (land) equals to a 1 bit while each spot where the light is reflected with a lower intensity (pit) equals to a 0 bit. However Blu-Ray and HD-DVD players use the transition between pits and lands or lands and pits to represent a 1 bit and the absence of such transitions to represent a 0 bit.

Each bit read this way is called an optical bit. They still do not represent directly a data 0 or 1. A process known as modulation is still required to convert optical bits into data bits. HD-DVD uses a modulation technique called ETM (Eight to Twelve Modulation), which converts each group of eight data bits (one byte) into 12 optical bits. Blue-Ray uses a modulation technique called 17PP that converts a variable number of optical bits in data bits based on rules defined by the modulation algorithm.

Just like what happens on CDs and DVDs, on Blu-Ray and HD-DVD discs pits and lands are organized into a single spiral track that starts at the center of the disc and ends at the border of the disc. The smaller the distance between the spiral tracks, more data can be stored on the disc. On Blu-Ray discs this distance is smaller than on HD-DVD discs (0.32 m vs. 0.40 m, respectively).

Also, on Blu-Ray discs each pit measures 0.13 m, while on HD-DVD discs they measure 0.20 m.

But why do HD-DVD discs use bigger pits compared to Blu-Ray if both use a laser with the same wavelength? The answer is the distance between the recording layer and the lacquer layer. On Blu-Ray discs the recording layer is only 0.1 mm distant from the lacquer layer, which allows a higher recording density (HD-DVD discs use the same distance as DVDs, 0.6 mm). On the other hand Blu-Ray discs must be handled more carefully, as any scratch on its surface can easily reach the recording layer, compromising the recorded data. That is why some Blu-Ray discs come inside a caddy in order to avoid physical damage.

As we can see, technologically speaking Blu-Ray and HD-DVD are very similar, the main difference between the two being the storage capacity.

A single-layer Blu-Ray disc can hold up to 25 GB, while a single-layer HD-DVD disc can hold up to "only" 15 GB. A dual-layer Blu-Ray disc can store up to 54 GB, while a dual-layer HD-DVD can store only up to 30 GB.

In the table below we summarized the main technical specs of Blu-Ray and HD-DVD discs.

Feature

Blu-Ray

HD-DVD

Capacity

  • 25 GB (single layer)
  • 54 GB (dual layer)
  • 15 GB (single layer)
  • 30 GB (dual layer)
  • Laser

    Blue-violet (0.40 m)

    Blue-violet (0.40 m)

    Pit width

    0.13 m

    0.20 m

    Distance between tracks

    0.32 m

    0.40 m

    Distance between the recording layer and the lacquer layer

    0.1 mm

    0.6 mm

    Supported codecs

  • MPEG-2
  • MPEG-4
  • AVC
  • VC-1
  • MPEG-2
  • MPEG-4
  • AVC
  • VC-1

  • In the table below you can see the main entertainment-related companies (i.e., movies and games) that support each technology.

    Blu-Ray

    HD-DVD

    • 20th Century Fox
    • Buena Vista Home Entertainment
    • Electronic Arts
    • MGM Studios
    • Paramount Pictures
    • Sony Pictures Entertainment
    • The Walt Disney Company
    • Vivendi Universal Games
    • Warner Bros.
    • Buena Vista Home Entertainment
    • New Line Cinema
    • Paramount Pictures
    • The Walt Disney Company
    • Universal Studios
    • Warner Bros.
    • The Weinstein Company/Genius

    Conclusions

    We still dont know which format will be DVDs successor. All we know is that still a fierce fight between the two standard, but on the storage size Blu-Ray has a better advantage over HD-DVD, while on the cost side HD-DVD is the winner, as HD DVD discs are cheaper to manufacture.

    As we saw, Blu-Ray discs have a higher storage capacity than HD-DVD, even though Blu-Ray discs are more expensive. A single-layer Blu-Ray disc can hold up to 25 GB while the same disc using HD-DVD technology can store only 15 GB. A dual-layer Blu-Ray discs can store up to 54 GB, while the same disc using HD-DVD technology can store only up to 30 GB.

    We are facing today the same infamous war between VHS and Betamax weve seen happening during the late 1970s and early 1980s. Which leads us to an interesting fact: Sony doesnt want adult movies on Blu-Ray format, the same restriction Betamax format had, and some critics say that this restriction was one of the reasons of Betamaxs demise. But since Sony isn't alone at the Blu-Ray consortium, we will see "adult" movies for this format as well, but it seems that producers at this industry prefer HD-DVD format over Blu-Ray.

    In terms of compatibility, both Blu-Ray and HD-DVD players will be capable of playing CDs and DVDs, but it wont be possible to read a Blu-Ray disc on a HD-DVD player and vice-versa (it is technically possible to create a player that can read both formats, but it will probably cost almost twice, as it will need two separated circuits inside the unit, one for each technology).

    For now DVD discs continue to be a good choice for the average Joe. If you are not a technology freak, wait until to see who will win this battle: Blu-Ray, HD-DVD or none of them.

    Originally at http://www.hardwaresecrets.com/article/Blu-Ray-vs-HD-DVD/415


    2004-13, Hardware Secrets, LLC. All Rights Reserved.

    Total or partial reproduction of the contents of this site, as well as that of the texts available for downloading, be this in the electronic media, in print, or any other form of distribution, is expressly forbidden. Those who do not comply with these copyright laws will be indicted and punished according to the International Copyrights Law.

    We do not take responsibility for material damage of any kind caused by the use of information contained in Hardware Secrets.