Hardware Secrets
Home | Audio | Case | Cooling | CPU | Input | Memory | Mobile | Motherboard | Networking | Power | Storage | Video | Other
Content
Articles
First Look
News
Reviews
Tutorials
Main Menu
About Us
Compare Prices
Datasheets
Dictionary
Download
Drivers
Forums
Gabriel's Blog
Links
Manufacturer Finder
Newsletter
On The Web
RSS Feed
Test Your Skills
Newsletter
Subscribe today!
Search




Recommended Book
Power Supply Cookbook (EDN Series for Design Engineers) (EDN Series for Design Engineers)
By Marty Brown
Newnes
Price: $40.07

Home » Power
Huntkey Green Star 450 W Power Supply Review
Author: Gabriel Torres
Type: Reviews Last Updated: March 24, 2008
Page: 6 of 8
$ Check REAL-TIME pricing for OCZ600SXS 600-Watt Power Supply $
eBay: $59.99 Dell: $70.99
CompUSA.com: $79.99 Circuit City: $93.95
Egoodz: $81.99 Newegg: $79.99

Load Tests

We made several tests with this power supply as described in the article Hardware Secrets Power Supply Test Methodology. All the tests described below were taken with a room temperature between 44º C and 48º C. During our tests the power supply temperature was between 49º C and 53º C.

First we tested this power supply with six different loads patterns, trying to pull around 20%, 40%, 60%, 80% and 100% (two patterns) of its labeled maximum capacity (under “% Max Load” we list the actual percentage that was used), watching how the reviewed unit behaved under each load. On the table below we list the load patterns we used and the results for each load.

For the 100% load testing we used two different load patterns and we need to explain why. The load pattern used on our test five was created in order to simulate a typical PC usage today, with most power being pulled from the 12 V outputs, because the CPU (thru ATX12V and EPS12V connectors) and the video card (thru auxiliary PCI Express connector) are connected to them. This configuration, however, surpassed the maximum specs printed on the product box – 286 W for the +12 V outputs (we were pulling 384 W during this pattern). During this test our power supply exploded (more precisely the switching transistors burned).

Even though we knew that when the switching transistors burn the problem is with the overall power (which is higher than the maximum supported by the power supply) and not with any of the individual power supply outputs being overloaded (because when this happens the secondary rectifiers are the components that burn) we decided to re-test this power supply respecting its maximum limits printed on the product box. To do that we bought a new power supply and reconfigured our load test to use test number six as the test for maximum load for this power supply. The result was what we expected: our second power supply exploded just like the first one since, like we explained, the problem wasn’t on the power configuration of the outputs but with the power supply maximum overall power. This time we taped the test and we will talk more about it below.

+12V2 is the second +12V input of our load tester and on this test it was connected to the power supply EPS12V connector. Since this connector was the only one connected to the power supply +12V2 rail, the +12V1 and +12V2 inputs from our load tester were really connected to the +12V1 and +12V2 virtual rails from the reviewed power supply.

If you add all the powers listed for each test you may find a value different from what posted under “Total” below. Since each output can have a slight variation (e.g. +5 V output working at 5.10 V) the actual total amount of power being delivered is slightly different from the calculated value. On “Total” row we are using the real amount of power being delivered, as measured by our load tester.

Input Test 1 Test 2 Test 3 Test 4 Test 5 Test 6
+12V1 3 A (36 W) 6.5 A (78 W) 10 A (120 W) 13 A (156 W) 17 A (204 W) 12 A (144 W)
+12V2 3 A (36 W) 6.5 A (78 W) 9 A (108 W) 12.5 A (150 W) 15 A (180 W) 11.5 A (138 W)
+5V 1 A (5 W) 2 A (10 W) 4 A (20 W) 5 A (25 W) 6 A (30 W) 18 A (90 W)
+3.3 V 1 A (3.3 W) 2 A (6.6 W) 4 A (13.2 W) 5 A (16.5 W) 6 A (19.8 W) 16.5 A (54.45 W)
+5VSB 1 A (5 W) 1 A (5 W) 1 A (5 W) 1.5 A (7.5 W) 2 A (10 W) 2 A (10 W)
-12 V 0.5 A (6 W) 0.5 A (6 W) 0.5 A (6 W) 0.5 A (6 W) 0.5 A (6 W) 0.5 A (6 W)
Total 90.3 W 181.4 W 269.7 W 356.9 W 449.9 W 451 W
% Max Load 20.1% 40.3% 59.9% 79.3% 99.9% 100.2%
Result Pass Pass Pass Pass Fail Fail
Voltage Stability Pass Pass Pass Pass Fail Fail
Ripple and Noise Pass Pass Pass Pass Fail Fail
AC Power 112 215 325 485 Fail Fail
Efficiency 80.6% 84.4% 83.0% 73.6% FailFail

Like we said Huntkey 450 W (LW-6450SG) exploded when we tried to pull 450 W from it using a load pattern that respects the limits printed on the product box (test six) and also using a load pattern that pulls more power from 12 V outputs and less power from 5 V and 3.3 V outputs (test five). This means that this power supply isn’t capable of delivering its labeled power in continuous mode being, as matter of fact, a 360 W power supply.

You can follow our test number six (i.e. our test with the second power supply we bought) on the below video. On this video you first see how our load tester was configured, which is exactly what is described on the table above on the “test 6” column. Then we changed the machine to display the power being pulled by the power supply and, after that, we turn on the CA main power from the power supply. The power supply was initially turned off and delivering only standby voltage (+5VSB). Then we turned on our power supply and you can see it pulling 450 W from our load tester. On top of the load tester there is our thermometer, showing the power supply temperature (above) and the temperature inside our “hot box” (below). It is hard to read it because of the video compression, but when we turned on the power supply temperature inside the box was around 41.5º C, below what we wanted for our methodology (we always test power supplies with a room temperature between 45º C and 50º C). In less than 2 minutes the power supply explodes. Check it out. In order to not being accused of uploading a fake video, we didn’t make any kind of editing and that’s why we didn’t put our logo or any text explaining what is going on.

When we opened the power supply we tested all main components and found out that the two switching transistors and two of their bias resistors had burned, check out on the pictures below the evidences we found.

Huntkey Green Star 450 W (LW-6450SG)
click to enlarge
Figure 16: Explosion marks on the Green Star 450 W housing. 

Huntkey Green Star 450 W (LW-6450SG)
click to enlarge
Figure 17: Two resistors exploded together with the switching transistors.

Keep in mind that we have already posted reviews of two other power supplies that use the same old design used by this unit (Seventeam ST-420BKV and Kingwin ABT-450MM), but contrary to this Huntkey model these units could deliver their rated power. Also both power supplies shut down when we tried to pull much more power that they can deliver, as their protections kicked in.

Another power supply from this same power range that we have recently reviewed and that couldn't deliver its labeled power was Thermaltake PurePower 430 W NP, which is in fact a 350 W power supply. But this model from Thermaltake didn't explode when we tried to pull 430 W, as the over power protection (OPP) circuit entered in action.

Another clear problem was efficiency. On the product box the manufacturer says that “efficiency exceeds 85% under full load”, which is a lie. On their website, however, they say this power supply has a minimum efficiency of 70% under full load and 50% under 30 W load, which makes more sense. Efficiency was between 80.6% and 84.4% during tests 1, 2 and 3, dropping to 73.6% during test 4, where we were pulling 80% of the maximum labeled power (357 W). We couldn’t measure efficiency under full load as the power supply exploded. So if you pull only up to 270 W this power supply will have an excellent efficiency.

On the tests the power supply worked correctly, voltages were really stable, inside a 3% limit from the nominal voltage – which is really great, as the limit is 5% –, except the -12 V output. This output was at -11.20 V and -11.41 on tests 1 and 2. Even though ATV12V standard sets -12 V tolerance at 10% (which means it can go from -10.80 V to -13.20 V) we would like to see this output closer to the nominal -12 V voltage.

Even though electrical noise was low during tests 1, 2 and 3 (below 12 mV on +5 V and +3.3 V rails and between 33.8 mV and 45.6 mV at +12V1 and between 42.4 mV and 59 mV at +12V2), it increased a lot during test 4, with noise on +12V2 rail reaching 90.4 mV (the limit is 120 mV).

Unfortunately we couldn’t capture screenshots from noise this time as the power supply exploded.

Pages (8): « 1 2 3 4 5 [6] 7 8 »
Print Version | Send to Friend | | Bookmark Article | Comments (17)

Related Content
  • Why 99% of Power Supply Reviews Are Wrong
  • How Much Power Can a Generic 500 W Power Supply Really Deliver?
  • SilverStone Strider ST50F 500 W Power Supply Review
  • Rocketfish 700 W Power Supply Review
  • Dynex 400 W Power Supply Review

  • Recommended Deals
    Pc Power and Cooling SILENCER® 410 (S41D2) 450-Watt Power Supply


    Buy.com: $66.41 Newegg: $149.99
    Dynapower TC-1000PC (TC-1000PC) 1000-Watt Power Supply


    Compunet-sol: $208.57 Circuitcity: $229.99
    Pc Power and Cooling PPCS750QBL 750-Watt Power Supply


    Newegg.com: $154.99
    Pc Power and Cooling PSU|S75CF 750W RT 750-Watt Power Supply


    Newegg.com: $149.99 TigerDirect.com: $159.99
    CompUSA.com: $159.99 Amazon: $139.99
    Circuitcity: $182.99 Dell Small Business: $224.99

    RSSLatest News
    Patriot Launches SO-DIMM DDR3-2000
    September 5, 2008 - 7:28 AM PST
    Kingston Unveils HyperX SO-DIMM Memory Kit
    September 4, 2008 - 10:59 AM PST
    Thermaltake Launches V9 Case Series
    September 3, 2008 - 7:54 AM PST
    Sigma Launches 1,000 W Power Supply
    September 2, 2008 - 7:55 AM PST
    Intel Launches New Processors
    September 1, 2008 - 11:16 AM PST
    Scythe Launches Kaze Maru Case Fan
    September 1, 2008 - 10:24 AM PST
    Lian Li Launches Silent Force Power Supply Series
    August 29, 2008 - 9:24 AM PST
    New Thermaltake Power Supplies
    August 28, 2008 - 11:43 AM PST
    Sparkle and MSI Launch GeForce 9400 GT
    August 28, 2008 - 11:13 AM PST
    NZXT Unveils Whisper Full Tower Case
    August 28, 2008 - 10:39 AM PST
    .:: More News ::.

    RSSLatest Content
    Everything You Need to Know About the CPU C-States Power Saving Modes
    AMD ATI Chips Comparison Table
    nVidia Chips Comparison Table
    Inside Intel Nehalem Microarchitecture
    OCZ Elixir Gaming Keyboard Review
    Everything You Need to Know About The QuickPath Interconnect (QPI)
    Me and Woz
    Introduction to Wireless USB (WUSB)
    Nikon Coolpix S600 Camera Review
    IDF Fall 2008: Opening Keynote
    Thecus N5200 NAS Review
    ECS GeForce 9800 GTX+ Hydra Video Card Review
    320 GB Hard Disk Drive Round-Up
    Razer Destructor Mouse Pad Review
    Sapphire HD 4870 X2 Video Card Review

    Our Most Popular Articles
    Maximum CPU Temperature
    771,260 views
    nVidia Chips Comparison Table
    479,768 views
    AMD ATI Chips Comparison Table
    425,285 views
    ATI Radeon X1300 Pro Review
    413,674 views
    ATI Radeon X1600 XT Review
    408,454 views
    How to Find Out Your Motherboard Manufacturer and Model
    384,396 views
    Connecting Two PCs Using a USB-USB Cable
    347,295 views
    How To Correctly Apply Thermal Grease
    332,529 views
    Sempron vs. Athlon XP
    279,980 views
    Sempron 3400+ Review
    270,141 views

    Latest Threads in Our Forums
    Building PC for Audio.
    by Wall'E
    What configuration is better??
    by Gabriel Torres
    Upgrading to dual core
    by Gabriel Torres
    Patriot Launches SO-DIMM DDR3-2000
    by Hardware Secrets Team
    overclocking e8400 problem
    by andybarrel
    Everything You Need to Know About the CPU C-States Power Saving Modes
    by Hardware Secrets Team
    Cooler Master Cosmos S Case Review
    by Retratserif
    Kingston Unveils HyperX SO-DIMM Memory Kit
    by Hardware Secrets Team
    New Forum: PC Doesn't Turn On
    by Gabriel Torres
    Computer Not Turning On? Read This First!
    by Gabriel Torres
    .:: Visit Our Forums ::.

    © 2004-8, Hardware Secrets, LLC. All rights reserved.
    Advertising | Legal Information | Privacy Policy
    All times are Pacific Standard Time (PST, GMT -08:00)